Replication over SSL should be set up in stages so that you can verify everything as you go through the process.
Before attempting to configure replication over a secure connection, you should complete the following tasks (in any order):
If you are only trying to set up replication to authenticate using a DN and a password over a secure connection, the preceding steps have done this for you. Authentication using a client certificate requires a different credentials object to be used by the supplier server in its agreement, as well as configuring the consumer server to accept that certificate as a supplier server.